Tawarruq: Jurisprudential Foundations and Contemporary Applications

Tawarruq is a form of transaction discussed in classical Islamic jurisprudence and widely employed in contemporary Islamic finance. The term derives from wariq, meaning silver or silver coins, and reflects the underlying purpose of obtaining ready cash. In Ḥanbalī jurisprudence, tawarruq refers to purchasing a commodity on deferred payment terms and subsequently selling it to a third party, rather than the original seller, for immediate cash, usually at a lower price.[1] The same arrangement is also discussed in certain Shāfiʿī works under the name zarnaqah.[2]

Bayʿ al-ʿĪnah: Sale and Repurchase for Cash

If a person buys a commodity on credit at a higher price and then sells it back to the same seller for a lower cash price, the transaction is known as bayʿ al-ʿīnah. The Ḥanafī,[3] Mālikī[4] and Ḥanbalī[5] schools regard this form of sale as prohibited.

The Shāfiʿī school takes a different position. Imām al-Nawawī writes:

“Bayʿ al-ʿīnah is not among the prohibited forms of sale. It occurs when a person sells an item to another for a deferred price, delivers it, and then, before receiving the price, buys it back for a lower cash price. Similarly, it is permissible to sell for cash and buy back for a higher deferred price, whether or not the first price has been received, and whether or not ʿīnah has become a person’s regular practice or is widespread in the locality. This is the sound, well-known position recorded in the books of the school’s scholars. However, Ustādh Abū Isḥāq al-Isfarāyinī and Shaykh Abū Muḥammad gave the fatwā that if this practice becomes habitual, the second sale comes to resemble a condition stipulated in the first, in which case both sales become invalid.”[6]

Thus, according to the predominant Shāfiʿī position, bayʿ al-ʿīnah and other comparable transactions used to avoid interest-bearing dealings are legally valid but disliked (makrūh). Ibn Ḥajar al-Haytamī makes this point explicitly.[7] It is important, however, that the first sale should not contain a condition requiring the buyer to sell the commodity back. If such a condition is included in the contract, the transaction becomes prohibited.[8] The buyer must remain free to keep the commodity, sell it back, or sell it to someone else.

A similar arrangement may involve more than two parties. Suppose A buys a mobile phone from B for ₹1,000. A then sells the phone to C for ₹1,500, payable at a later date. C immediately sells it back to B for ₹1,000 in cash. Three transactions have taken place. As a result, A is owed ₹1,500 and C receives ₹1,000 in cash. This is a somewhat less direct form than the sale-and-buyback arrangement described above. Within the Shāfiʿī school, such sales are recognised as valid so long as no invalidating condition is made part of the contracts. The details and rulings of similar transactions can be found under buyūʿ al-ājāl (sales involving deferred payment) in Mālikī jurisprudence[9] and under al-bayʿ al-fāsid (defective sales) in Ḥanafī jurisprudence.[10]

Where the buyer sells the commodity to an independent third party rather than returning it to the original seller, the transaction is called tawarruq, or zarnaqah. Abū Manṣūr al-Azharī al-Harawī explains: “This is when a person buys a commodity for a deferred price and then sells it for cash to someone other than the seller. It is permissible according to all jurists.” He also relates that ʿĀʾishah (may Allah be pleased with her) used to engage in zarnaqah.[11]

Ibn al-Qayyim distinguishes between the two arrangements: “If the person in need sells the commodity back to its seller, it is ʿīnah; if he sells it to someone else, it is tawarruq.”[12]

This distinction does not mean that the permissibility of tawarruq has always been unanimous. Ibn Taymiyyah objected to the practice, and Ibn al-Qayyim, while distinguishing it from ʿīnah, also questioned the use of a commodity sale merely to obtain cash against a larger future obligation. Their objection was directed not only at the outward form of the contracts but also at the financial result they produced. Thus, the favourable account found in many classical works has to be read alongside a recognised line of juristic criticism.[13]

Since the Shāfiʿī school recognises even bayʿ al-ʿīnah as valid in the circumstances described above, the permissibility of ordinary tawarruq follows all the more readily. Imām al-Shāfiʿī himself states that there is no objection to a person selling, for cash, a commodity bought on credit, whether to the original seller or to someone else.[14] The discussions in Ḥanafī,[15] Mālikī[16] and Ḥanbalī[17] works also recognise the permissibility of selling to an independent third party for a lower cash price, although the schools differ on related forms and conditions.

Tawarruq in Islamic Banking

Many Islamic banks use tawarruq to provide financing as an alternative to interest-bearing loans. The arrangement used in banking, however, is more complex than the straightforward transaction described in classical works of fiqh. It ordinarily involves several connected steps.

A simple example makes the banking arrangement easier to follow. Suppose a customer needs ₹100,000 in cash. The bank purchases an identifiable quantity of aluminium for ₹100,000 and sells it to the customer for ₹120,000, payable in agreed instalments. Once the customer has acquired the commodity, it is sold to an independent trader for ₹100,000 in cash. The customer has obtained the amount required but owes the bank ₹120,000 under the deferred sale.

  1. A customer approaches an Islamic bank seeking a specified amount of financing and promises to purchase commodities from the bank for a corresponding amount.
  2. On the strength of the customer’s promise, the bank purchases commodities from an international market. These may include metals other than gold and silver, such as platinum, aluminium or iron, or other goods such as sugar, whose prices are relatively stable. Some banks purchase and hold such commodities regularly rather than waiting for an individual customer’s request. The goods usually remain in the relevant warehouse. Ownership is transferred into the bank’s name in the warehouse records, together with the associated responsibility. Instead of physical possession (qabḍ ḥaqīqī), there is constructive possession (qabḍ ḥukmī). The prevailing juristic position recognises constructive possession in sales other than currency exchange, provided its requirements are genuinely met.[18]

The reference to constructive possession should not, however, be reduced to the issue of a certificate. If a bank purchases a specified quantity of metal held in a warehouse, it must be possible to establish what was bought, where it is held, and whether the bank has acquired an enforceable right to dispose of or take delivery of it. An electronic entry may record a genuine transfer, but a document representing goods that cannot be identified or delivered does not, by itself, settle the question of qabḍ. The allocation of ownership risk during this interval is equally relevant.[19]

  1. Once the commodity has come under the bank’s ownership and constructive possession, evidenced for example by an appropriate certificate or warehouse record, the bank sells it to the customer at a higher agreed price that includes its profit. This is a murābaḥah sale and is a recognised form of sale in Islamic jurisprudence.[20] The customer also receives constructive possession: ownership is transferred to the customer, who is entitled to collect the commodity from its place of storage if desired. Alternatively, the purchaser may authorise the appointment of an independent third party to receive it. The original seller cannot himself receive the goods as the buyer’s agent, but the appointment of a separate person for receipt is recognised.[21] The customer agrees to pay the purchase price by instalments. Some institutions instead agree on a price without disclosing the original cost and profit margin; that is a musāwamah sale. Both murābaḥah and musāwamah are recognised forms of sale.
  2. After obtaining constructive possession of the commodity, the customer appoints the bank as an agent (wakīl) to sell it to a third party for cash. Under the Shāfiʿī school, an agency appointment made before the commodity has entered the customer’s ownership and possession would not be valid in the arrangement under discussion.[22] The customer must also have a genuine choice about what to do with the goods. The bank may not make their resale through itself a compulsory condition of the customer’s purchase.

The bank’s appointment as resale agent is one of the most disputed elements of contemporary tawarruq. AAOIFI Sharīʿah Standard No. 30, clauses 4/7–4/9, generally requires the customer to sell the commodity personally or through an agent other than the institution from which it was purchased. It permits delegation to that institution in a limited regulatory circumstance, after the customer has taken actual or constructive possession.[23] Malaysia’s tawarruq policy, on the other hand, accommodates agency and certain dual-agency arrangements, provided that the contracts are properly sequenced and evidenced.[24] The two approaches differ in details, even though both require a genuine sale and effective transfer of ownership.

  1. Acting under the customer’s authority, the bank sells the commodity and deposits the cash proceeds into the customer’s account.

Today these transactions may be completed through electronic platforms, sometimes within seconds. Bursa Suq Al-Silaʿ in Malaysia, for example, was established to facilitate commodity murābaḥah and tawarruq transactions for Islamic financial institutions.[25] Automation does not dispense with the legal requirements of successive sales. Bank Negara Malaysia’s Sharīʿah Advisory Council permitted straight-through processing subject, among other things, to correct sequencing, the identification of the commodity by location, quantity and quality, evidence of ownership and its attendant risks, and the purchaser’s right to delivery.[26]

Where the conditions set out above are fulfilled, this form of transaction may be regarded as permissible, particularly where it is used to avoid interest-bearing borrowing. Under the Shāfiʿī approach, a contract is not invalidated merely by the parties’ prior understanding or intentions, provided that its contractual terms do not contain an invalidating condition.[27] At the same time, Ibn Ḥajar al-Haytamī describes bayʿ al-ʿīnah and other disputed devices used to avoid ribā as disliked.[28] His observation suggests that even an otherwise valid arrangement of this kind may fall within the category of makrūh.

Other scholars disagree. They hold that the organised nature of these sales, and the prior coordination between the parties, undermine their validity. The International Islamic Fiqh Academy has taken the position that organised tawarruq and reverse tawarruq are not permissible, since they involve explicit or implicit collusion to obtain immediate cash against a larger deferred liability.[29]

The Academy’s objection is directed particularly at the prearranged conversion of a commodity into cash, where the financier or its associates organise the successive sales so that the customer effectively receives a smaller immediate amount against a larger deferred debt. This is more than a disagreement about the number of contracts. It concerns the independence of the second sale, the reality of the commodity transfer, and whether an arrangement that appears to consist of sales functions in substance as a cash loan carrying an increase. The Academy nevertheless distinguishes this organised structure from classical tawarruq undertaken through valid, independent sales.[30]

Contemporary regulation illustrates the continuing difference in approach. While the Malaysian framework regulates tawarruq-based products and their execution, the State Bank of Pakistan adopted AAOIFI Sharīʿah Standard No. 30 in October 2026, subject to its stated clarifications and accompanying guidance on the application of ḥājah (need). Such differences do not eliminate the underlying fiqh debate; they show how national Sharīʿah authorities have responded differently.[31]

Some Islamic banks also use tawarruq in issuing credit cards. Bank Islam Malaysia, for example, offers a credit-card facility structured around tawarruq. The basic commodity transactions follow the general arrangement already described, except that the proceeds from selling the commodity are credited to a facility account linked to the customer’s card. In some banking arrangements, a similar mechanism has also been used to settle outstanding card obligations.[32]

AmBank Islamic announced in November 2025 that it would convert its Islamic credit cards from an ujrah-based structure to tawarruq.[33] In July 2026, Bank Negara Malaysia issued further directions addressing the treatment of tawarruq proceeds and cardholder repayments, as well as questions concerning cash-advance and annual fees.[34] These developments show that the fiqh inquiry does not end when the initial commodity sale is completed. The legal character of money held in the card account, the treatment of repayments, the calculation of rebates (ibrāʾ), and the basis for fees must also be considered.

Reverse Tawarruq

Another form is reverse tawarruq. Here, the bank rather than the customer receives the immediate cash. The arrangement is therefore used to mobilise deposits for the bank.

The customer purchases commodities in the international market for cash through the bank and then sells them to the bank at a higher deferred price. The bank pays that price to the customer over an agreed period. It subsequently sells the commodities back into the international market to convert them into cash.

For example, a depositor may purchase a commodity for ₹100,000 and sell it to the bank at a deferred price of ₹105,000, payable on an agreed future date. The difference is the price markup in a sale, not a share of the bank’s business profits. This distinction matters: a tawarruq-based term deposit should not be described as a muḍārabah investment in which the depositor participates in actual profits and bears the corresponding investment risk. The fixed debt arising from the deferred sale has its own contractual character. AAOIFI Standard No. 30 is particularly restrictive about an institution using tawarruq to mobilise funds for its ordinary operations and reserves such recourse for circumstances of serious liquidity need.[35]

In practice, banks do not always observe the required conditions concerning possession (qabḍ), agency (wakālah) for purchasing and selling, and the stipulations incorporated into the contracts. Failure to observe these conditions can render the transactions invalid.

The practical concerns are not merely theoretical. A customer may never see the commodity, yet still possess it constructively if its identification, ownership, control and delivery rights are genuine. Conversely, elaborate electronic documentation cannot validate a sale of an asset that the seller did not own or could not deliver. Similar questions arise where the same commodity is repeatedly circulated among linked brokers, where the customer has no effective choice about resale, or where an agent executes a sale before its principal has acquired the asset. Each case must be examined through the actual contracts and trading records rather than its product name alone.

Tawarruq thus occupies a difficult position in contemporary Islamic finance. It can offer a means of obtaining liquidity through sales rather than an interest-bearing loan, and a number of jurists recognise its classical form. Yet the increasing organisation and automation of commodity trading bring questions that the simple classical example does not answer by itself.

Reference:

[1]  Al-Buhūtī, Sharḥ Muntahā al-Irādāt, 2:158.

[2]  Abū Manṣūr Muḥammad ibn Aḥmad al-Azharī al-Harawī, al-Zāhir fī Gharīb Alfāẓ al-Shāfiʿī, p. 143 . 

[3]  Al-Kāsānī, Badāʾiʿ al-Ṣanāʾiʿ, 5:198.

[4]  Al-Ḥaṭṭāb, Mawāhib al-Jalīl, 4:404.

[5]  Ibn Qudāmah, al-Mughnī, 6:260.

[6]  Al-Nawawī, Rawḍat al-Ṭālibīn, 3:419, section on bayʿ al-ʿīnah. 

[7]  Ibn Ḥajar al-Haytamī, Tuḥfat al-Muḥtāj, 4:323.

[8]  Al-Subkī, Takmilat Sharḥ al-Muhadhdhab (continuation of al-Majmūʿ), 10:157.

[9]  Al-Ḥaṭṭāb, Mawāhib al-Jalīl, 4:393; al-Sharḥ al-Kabīr, 3:89; Jawāhir al-Iklīl, 2:33.

[10]  Al-Sarakhsī, al-Mabsūṭ, 13:127; al-Kāsānī, Badāʾiʿ al-Ṣanāʾiʿ, 5:199; Ibn ʿĀbidīn, Ḥāshiyah, 5:365.

[11]  Al-Azharī al-Harawī (d. 370 AH), al-Zāhir fī Gharīb Alfāẓ al-Shāfiʿī, p. 143.

[12]  Ibn al-Qayyim, Iʿlām al-Muwaqqiʿīn, 3:128 (edition cited). Ibn al-Qayyim draws the terminological distinction but goes on to criticise tawarruq;

[13]  On the disagreement, see Ibn al-Qayyim, Iʿlām al-Muwaqqiʿīn, discussion of tawarruq and Ibn Taymiyyah’s objection

[14]  Al-Shāfiʿī, al-Umm, 3:65

[15]  Ibn ʿĀbidīn, Radd al-Muḥtār, 4:114; Sharḥ al-ʿInāyah, 6:69; al-Kāsānī, Badāʾiʿ al-Ṣanāʾiʿ, 5:199.

[16]  Al-Qawānīn al-Fiqhiyyah, p. 277; al-Naẓāʾir fī al-Fiqh, “2829” (page number reproduced from the original and requiring confirmation); al-Sharḥ al-Ṣaghīr, 3:117.

[17]  Maʿūnat Ūlī al-Nuhā, 4:67; al-Mubdiʿ, 4:49; al-Furūʿ, 6:316.

[18]  Ḥāshiyat al-Shirwānī, 7:101. Whether a particular warehouse arrangement amounts to valid constructive possession depends on the actual transfer of control and risk.

[19]  Bank Negara Malaysia, Tawarruq Policy Document, 28 December 2018, sections on the underlying asset, ownership and possession; see also the Sharīʿah Advisory Council ruling on straight-through processing, 26 November 2019 (released 19 May 2020).  [Source]

[20]  For a fuller explanation of murābaḥah, see the chapter on murābaḥah in the original work.

[21]  Ibn Ḥajar al-Haytamī, Tuḥfat al-Muḥtāj, 5:297, on appointing a third party to receive the goods. 

[22]  Ibn Ḥajar al-Haytamī, Tuḥfat al-Muḥtāj, 5:301.

[23]  AAOIFI, Sharīʿah Standard No. 30, Monetization (Tawarruq), clauses 4/7–4/9. The limited exception under clause 4/7 concerns circumstances in which regulations do not allow the customer to sell other than through the institution.  [Source]

[24]  Bank Negara Malaysia, Tawarruq Policy Document (2018), section 17 on dual-agency and section 18 on promises.   [Source]

[25]  Bursa Malaysia, Bursa Assist, “What is Bursa Suq Al-Silaʿ (BSAS)?”, updated 13 November 2025.  [Source]

[26]  Bank Negara Malaysia, Sharīʿah Advisory Council, ruling at its 199th meeting (26 November 2019), released 19 May 2020, on straight-through processing of tawarruq transactions.  [Source]

[27]  Ibn Ḥajar al-Haytamī, Tuḥfat al-Muḥtāj, 4:296.

[28]  Ibn Ḥajar al-Haytamī, Tuḥfat al-Muḥtāj, 4:323.

[29]  International Islamic Fiqh Academy, Resolution No. 179 (19/5), “Tawarruq: Its Reality and Types (Classical and Organised Banking Tawarruq),” Sharjah, 26–30 April 2009. The resolution specifically prohibits organised and reverse tawarruq.  [Online text]

[30]  International Islamic Fiqh Academy, Resolution No. 179 (5/19), “Essence and Types of Tawaruq (Fiqh Compliant vs Bank Structured),” 26–30 April 2009, particularly its distinction between classical and organised tawarruq.  [Source]

[31]  State Bank of Pakistan, IFPD Circular No. 03 of 2026, 16 October 2026, adopting AAOIFI Sharīʿah Standard No. 30 subject to national clarifications and guidance on the application of ḥājah.  [Source]

[32]  Bank Islam Malaysia Berhad, Bank Islam Credit Card-i Terms & Conditions, effective 25 July 2025, especially the description of the tawarruq facility and commodity transactions.   [Online text]

[33]  AmBank Islamic, “Conversion of the Underlying Shariah Principle of AmBank Islamic Credit Cards-i,” notice dated 17 November 2025.  [Source]

[34]  Bank Negara Malaysia, Sharīʿah Advisory Council statement on cash-advance fees, annual fees and ujrah- and tawarruq-based credit cards, issued 3 July 2026, especially the discussion of the legal character of proceeds and repayments.  [Source]

[35]  AAOIFI, Sharīʿah Standard No. 30, Monetization (Tawarruq), clause 5/1, concerning tawarruq where the financial institution is the beneficiary of liquidity.  [Source]

Disclaimer

The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily mirror Islamonweb’s editorial stance.

Leave A Comment

Related Posts